Category Archives: downtown retailing

Downtown Vacancies: Let’s Get Real

Posted on by
________________

A slightly different version of this article appeared as a Perspectives Column in the May 15, 2009 issue of the Downtown Idea Exchange

________________

Far too often, concern about the number of empty storefronts in a downtown reaches distorted and needlessly injurious proportions. This was true before our current recession and now it threatens to become an even more serious problem. It’s critical for downtown leaders to view the vacancy rate issue from a realistic perspective.

For example, a few years ago, when I was managing a district, the mayor and I often would go around the block about our vacancies. My protestations that our vacancy rate of 2.6% was very low, and one that most other districts would love to have, were dismissed – the mayor wanted a zero vacancy rate. I tried to explain that a zero rate actually would be unhealthy for the district because it would keep out new business blood and thus make the district stale, perhaps even ossified. This argument, too, gained no traction. And this mayor is a very bright and likeable guy.

Today, many downtown leaders and local politicians are seeing growing vacancies as omens of doom. In past recessions, DANTH Inc. had projects in downtowns where the vacancy rates were in the 18% to 20% range. Looking just at the vacancy numbers is deceiving. High numbers are not a death warrant:

  • Within a year, the downtown with the 20% rate recruited several trophy retailers and substantially reduced the number of vacancies. A few years later it was being cited as a veritable model of downtown revitalization.
  • Similarly, the other downtown reduced its rate to 12% in less than a year and to 6% after 18 months. Today it reports having few vacancies.

A recent canvass of 14 downtowns showed four with vacancy rates of 10% or higher. But:

  • Two of those downtowns had actually reduced their vacancy rates substantially during 2008 from 2007: one dropped to 11.2% from 14.1% and the other to 11% from 15%.
  • Another of the canvassed downtowns reported a 13.3% vacancy rate. On the other hand, it still had at least six new stores open, some of which promise to be strong. Moreover, a supermarket is doubling its size, a new nursing home with new ground floor retail space is about to be built, 14 residential units are being added to the floor above an existing 15,000-s.f. retail space, and McDonald’s will be renovating a 100-plus-foot façade on the main drag.
  • Most of the canvassed downtowns reported new shops were opening, even when the district managers felt the vacancy rates were much higher than they would like.

In the vast majority of downtowns a very significant proportion of the storefronts normally are occupied by marginal operations. Very often, marginal businesses are badly managed and do little to foster a positive image of the district. In a recession marginal firms have a high probability of failing. Some marginal firms are not small – many national retail chains are now out of business because mismanagement put them on the financial brink and the recession pushed them over.

The vacancies that result from this economic pruning can – and I would argue should – be viewed as opportunities. In tough times like these, there still is “creative destruction” and many district managers are reporting that some attractive new businesses are opening. If these firms survive the recession, they probably will really thrive when the economy rebounds.

Many would argue that a district is damaged more by a poor business operator who cannot garner customer support than by a vacant storefront. Let us not take our admiration of small business people to the point where we canonize all of them. By definition, half of the small business operators in this country are below average. The challenge in this recession is to fill the downtown vacancies with as many above average operators as we can. The quality of the existing tenants is more important than the quantity of empty stores!

Now is the time for downtowns to survive and reposition. Consequently, there are lots of better barometers than vacancies for judging how a downtown is doing during our current economic troubles:
• Have shops and eateries adapted to the new market realities so their owners can still make a satisfactory living?
• Are quality businesses opening?
• Are store facades being maintained and improved?
• Is land being quietly assembled for development when the economy rebounds? Better still, are projects actually going into construction?
• Are improvements being done to make the downtown a more convenient place to visit?
• Are investments being made to create terrific public spaces?

N. David Milder

More On Retailing To Teenagers

Posted on by

There was an interesting article by Eric Wilson in yesterday’s New York Times about retailers who target teenage shoppers. The full citation can be found at the end of this post.

Wilson notes that a recent study by the investment bank Piper Jaffray reported a 14% decline in spending by teenagers that was a “direct reflection of the economy.” Cost has become a much more important factor in teenager purchasing decisions.

Most importantly, Wilson notes that “as teenagers’ priorities rapidly shift away from brands they now perceive as too expensive, the pecking order of mall stores has changed.” Abercrombie & Fitch, for example, has held its prices during the current recession and consequently has had a significant decline in sales.

But, price is not everything., Hot Topic has increased its sales steadily during the recession largely because it sells licensed products tied to the “Twilight” vampire series. According to Betsy McLaughlin, the chain’s CEO: “There’s just so much retail out there. I think the people who will win are the ones who provide something different. It’s not just a price war.”

See: Eric Wilson, “Losing Its Cool at the Mall,” The New York Times, April 23, 2009, sec. Fashion & Style, Article.

 

Recession Evils: Rumors and Facile Solutions

Posted on by

In a recent newsletter of Red Bank’s RiverCenter, Nancy Adams properly admonished the rumor-mongers who, faster than the recession, can bring down a good business operation. I congratulate Nancy for her spunk. And in contrast to Lou Grant, a lot of us like spunk! I am so glad she told those idiots to shut up!

Let me take up a cudgel against an equal danger – the town leader, manager or guru who thinks they are on to an easy answer for coping with our Great Recession. For instance, since November I have been hearing on and off about how good the student market is for retailers. This flies directly against what I have leaned about student shoppers since I started to study them for a project in Elizabeth, NJ back in the late 1990s. Before the dot,com bubble burst, the teen/tween market was an important growth engine for many downtowns – especially in urban wear. But with the dot.com bust, these youths lost their biggest income – what mom and dad gave them. And a lot of shops that targeted this market were badly hurt. Also, this market is notoriously fickle – a shop or chain that is red hot today can be in the crapper tomorrow. Finally, the potential size of this market is limited – the amount that teens and tweens can spend simply pales in comparison to how much retail spending their mothers control!

Then, if you look closely at what is happening today, you have to wonder some more. You can bet your bottom dollar that as this recession deepens, these kids are going to get less and less from their parents. And do you really think these kids are now getting part-time jobs to cover their retail buying habits? Moreover, if you look at some recent data, the story is a mixed one; some retail chains that target the teen/tween market are doing really well, but others, many that were hugely popular with these young shoppers, are not.

Below are some same store sales comparisons for retail chains that like teen/tween customers. The data are from Barbara Farfan at About.com:

Same Store Sales –Dec 2008

+13.5% The Buckle, Inc.
+ 12% Aeropostale
+ 10% GameStop
+ 4.3% Hot Topic Inc.

– 1% Urban Outfitters
– 10% Pacific Sunwear
– 12.3% Zumiez
– 12.5% Wet Seal
– 17% American Eagle Outfitters
– 24% Abercrombie & Fitch

Same Store Sales –Jan 2009

+ 14.7% The Buckle Inc.
+ 11.0% Aeropostale
+ 6.0% Hot Topic
+ 2.0% American Apparel

– 11.0% Pacific Sunwear of California
– 14.8% Zumiez
– 20.0% Abercrombie & Fitch
– 22.0% American Eagle Outfitters

Same Store Sales –Feb 2009

+ 21.0% Buckle, Inc.
+ 11.0% Aeropostale
+ 10.8% Hot Topic
+ 4.8% Torrid (Hot Topic)
+ 3.0% Urban Outfitters

– 6.6% Wet Seal
– 9.0% American Apparel
– 13.0% Zumiez
– 23.9% Arden B (Wet Seal)
– 30.0% Abercrombie & Fitch

The Buckle, Hot Topic and Aeropostale are indeed doing well and it would be great to discern a winning formula they share. Hot Topic is hot because it sells the clothing that the vampires or zombies wear in some book series that tween and teen girls now adore. Gamestop is hot because it resells computer games to the avid gamesters. But, Ambercrombie’s, Amercian Eagle, Zumiez, Wet Seal and Pacific Sunwear are not flourishing. And Amercian Apparel and Urban Outfitters – some retail analysts thought they were immune to this recession – are up and down. This market segment still does not sound to me like a rock downtowns now can build their retail upon.

The Apparel Niche and the Home & Hearth Niche: The Growing Importance of Independent Operators

Posted on by

Introduction

The apparel niche and the home & hearth niche may seem unrelated, but they share several commonalities:

  • They are both particularly important to downtowns
  • They are both facing challenges, and
  • They will both be relying on the success of independent operators for their future well-being and growth.

Apparel

First, let’s consider apparel. This niche is important to downtowns because women are our most prominent and powerful shoppers (making 80% of the purchases for the home and family). And clothing, shoes and accessories purchases for themselves and their children are an important part of women’s purchases. As we’ve reported in previous blasts, time-pressured mothers are willing to accept higher prices from downtown vendors if they can shop quickly and easily close to home. In addition, a successful apparel niche adds diversity to the downtown mix and stimulates interest in strolling and window shopping.

But apparel has been an at-risk niche for the past two decades. While the industry has grown, it has grown at a pace much slower than other retail sectors. Additionally, major retailers like Ann Taylor, the Gap and Chico’s – the kind of trophy apparel shop that many downtowns have targeted as their dream tenants – are not opening new stores as they suffer reduced sales in a difficult economic climate.

What to do? We all know of downtowns where there is more than sufficient unmet demand for apparel within a ten-minute drive shed to support a new store with $300,000 to $400,000 in annual sales. Such revenue may be too low for a national chain, but very adequate for an independent operator.

These new merchants will need a great deal of support from the downtown organization in finding affordable space, negotiating leases and perhaps even “sourcing” their merchandise. To succeed it will help that these merchants:

  • Be a local resident – for instance, a local mother – with a network of friends and colleagues in the community
  • Represent and market to a specific and strongly populated ethnic group in the community
  • Be opening a very high-end shop that provides an exceptional level of pampering and customer service
  • Be able to solve the problem of sourcing attractive merchandise

In many instances, an independent operation apparel niche is not going to be recognized or realized without the proactive intervention of a downtown organization. Your organization can help foster such a niche by:

  • Having market research performed to identify opportunities
  • Indentifying and cultivating possible entrepreneurs
  • Helping the entrepreneurs form a viable business plan, find appropriate affordable space, find loans or investors, etc.

Home & Hearth

For decades, revitalization advocates have searched for a type of retailing that can thrive in downtown locations despite the presence of nearby malls and big box discount retailers. DANTH has found that home and hearth niches are very often the answer.

Home and hearth niches are groups of shops that feature goods and services that enable shoppers to make their homes more comfortable, more entertaining and more beautiful. They include retail establishments selling furniture, carpets, antiques, table top goods, window treatments, hardware, electronics, art works, picture frames, tiles, appliances, kitchen and bathroom equipment, plumbing supplies, telephones, and gardening equipment. This niche can also include architects, plumbers, carpenters, contractors and service firms that deal with lawns and septic tanks.

Usually, the firms in this niche are overwhelmingly independent operators or small regional chains. They usually don’t need vanilla box spaces.

The home and hearth niche is very dependent on the housing market and the niche’s current economic woes have traced the decline in home values. But DANTH believes that demand for this niche’s products and services soon will begin to grow as consumers start to put more money and attention into fixing up their current homes instead of buying new ones. Home Depot and Lowe’s have already pivoted their marketing in this direction. Economic conditions have also sent Americans into more “cocooning” in their homes which is leading to strong sales of flat screen TVs and other home theater accoutrements.

Plus, the long-term trend for this niche is very good, showing that businesses in the home and hearth sector have grown at a pace greater than GAFO in eight of the last ten years for which data are available. DANTH expects that as the current housing crisis is resolved and household formation again rises, sales in home and hearth stores will follow suit. Now, as the market is bottoming out, is a good time for downtown organizations to strengthen or build their home and hearth niches.

Another positive for this sector is that downtown organizations will need to do less work in attracting and building this niche than with an apparel niche – since less home and hearth business owners are “newbie’s” to the industry. The downtown organization can take on a more traditional business recruitment effort without having to provide the large amount of business development assistance that independent apparel operators will require.

This posting was condensed from my longer report by Mary Mann. To read the full report on Apparel and Home & Hearth Niches, visit www.ndavidmilder.com.

The Mommy Niche

Posted on by

Cultivating the Mommy Niche
In the last few postings, we have detailed the trends negatively impacting downtowns as the economy constricts, but we have also discussed strategies for overcoming those negative trends.

One such strategy for downtowns is building and/or strengthening the “Mommy Niche.”

The reason is simple: Women are our nation’s shoppers. Though they comprise little more than half the population, women make over 80% of the consumer purchasing decisions. Mothers with children make up about a third of all households and they are spending a lot of money.

Why will mothers be attracted to downtowns instead of regional malls or big box retailers? Mothers employed outside the home are the most time-pressured group and the one most likely to give convenience a heavy weight within their purchasing decisions. These mothers are looking for shorter shopping trips and are more inclined to “satisfice” (compromise between price and convenience) with merchandise available in their downtown shops. They are also looking to spend “quality time” with their children as conveniently as possible, and downtown restaurants and activities can provide the perfect venue.

Activity-Driven Retail
While women’s apparel and children’s apparel shops are very helpful, activities seems to be driving a lot of mommy niches. Family friendly restaurants are key. Restaurants that encourage children with play areas, baby and child-friendly restrooms – even toys – and affordable prices and kid-friendly food will attract mothers with young children. Another key factor is children’s learning centers – dance studios, art studios, kids yoga, karate, even the town library. Mothers can spend time with their children at these activities or drop their children off and be free to shop and catch up on salon needs, grocery shopping or buying presents.

This mix of services and activities provides a customer traffic flow of moms that downtown retailers and restaurants can capture.

Mommy Networks
Through their own social activities as well as their involvement in those of their children – car-pooling, preschool, soccer, etc. – mothers need to be networked with other parents. This need is especially strong for those who work outside of the home and rely on the networks to provide some level of care or supervision for their children. Consequently, in most communities there are strong “mommy” social networks that provide word-of-mouth communications channels.

Local “Mommy Merchants”
Over the past year, DANTH has noticed increased reports about local mothers opening commercial establishments in New Jersey downtowns. These “mommy merchants” have many assets that give them a higher probability of success. For example, they usually bring along networks of local friends who constitute a close-in customer base and cadres of likely store apostles. They are also more likely to be attuned to local mommy needs, tastes and shopping habits. Even more, they are sometimes friends of other district “mommy merchants” and these connections provide a spine for referrals and informal cross promotions. Many mommy merchants can probably use technical assistance. DANTH estimates that between 7% and 25% of downtown merchants are interested in obtaining and actually using such assistance. However, because of their high education attainment and prior professional experiences, it is likely that mommy merchants will have a higher participation rate in such programs.

Despite all this, few downtown revitalization strategies have a “mommy” focus.

How To Make A Mommy Niche Happen?
Downtown organizations need to think about how to make their districts more convenient for visitors, especially busy working mothers and /or stay-at-home moms. Thinking about physical improvements in terms of a “convenience analysis” is the first strategy. Downtowns need to have streets that are easy to cross, public toilets available and kid-friendly, parking that is easy and safe for mothers with children and strollers, short-term parking that generates lots of quick customer trips, and a reasonable distance between parking facilities to shopping and activity. Downtowns also have to cultivate relationships with their local mommy networks. This means identifying the networks and the women in them who are the opinion leaders and message transmitters. Hold focus groups with local mothers or arrange discussion groups between downtown business operators and local moms. Finally, help potential local “mommy entrepreneurs” prepare viable business plans, find downtown locations and link them to other sources of assistance such as business schools, the SBA and state economic development agencies.

This posting was condensed from my longer report by Mary Mann. For the full report on “Cultivating the Mommy Niche” and for a full citation of sources, visit www. DANTH.com after June 17, 2008.